001_Elkins, FRAGMENTS
(link to PDF)



RESEARCH FRAGMENTS ( • 
James Elkins. What Happened to Art Criticism? 2003.
Prepared by Katy Crocker for Parenthesis on 07 JULY 2026


















*



















[Apatelodes Torrefacta 
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apatelodes_torrefacta]





01. 

He* collected moths as a kid in Ithaca.




[source]
Elkins, James. “Extreme Ithacans: James Elkins on the Joy of Immersion in a Place,” Literary Hub via Unnamed Press, November 15, 2023,

https://lithub.com/extreme-ithacans-james-elkins-on-the-joy-of-immersion-in-a-place/.











02.

He collected 
the moths 
in the woods 
near Cornell.




[The woods near Cornell University, by unnamed photographer
https://ithacatrails.org/trail/danby-state-forest-chestnut-lean-to/]



[Olceclostera Angelica, photograph by Scott Camazine]
03.

He* still remembers their Latin names. 

This one's called an angel.



*He is James Elkins.






































      04.

“From my point of view what’s of interest is the articulation of seeing.”






 
[source]
“Andrew Carnegie Lecture Series - James Elkins.” The University of Edinburgh. December 7, 2017. 6:50 min. Video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2oFFWtHOaaU.



05.

This one's named after a sphinx, Pandora Sphinx moth. 



06. 

“They were individuals to me, without character but with sharp outlines in my memory, and always the Latin name: Apatelodes torrefacta, the Spotted Apatelodes moth, which always looked battered; Olceclostera angelica, the Angel Moth, like a Victorian woman in gray mourning; Eumorpha pandorus, the magnificent Pandora Sphinx moth. Those are names that still conjure trembling shadows projected by my flashlight, sharp cold evenings in pine forests, long bicycle rides to forests we’d secretly sugared.” 


[source]
https://lithub.com/extreme-ithacans-james-elkins-on-the-joy-of-immersion-in-a-place/.


















































08.

"skein of evanescent allusions" (26)

 
[source]
Elkins, James. What Happened to Art Criticism? Prickly Paradigm Press, 2003.
































































07.

"diaphanous veil" (6)

[source]
Elkins, James. What Happened to Art Criticism? Prickly Paradigm Press, 2003.


















09. 

“I walked through woods soundless as a ghost. The delighted eye of my memory regarded one thing and then another.” 



from Weak in Comparison to Dreams, 2023, by James Elkins, the third book in a five-part novel, titled Five Strange Languages.







10. 

“A ghostly profession, catering to ghosts, but in a grand style, referring to art criticism” (10).

 

[source]
Elkins, James. What Happened to Art Criticism? Prickly Paradigm Press, 2003.






11.

“My own list of most-interesting [art critics] includes Joseph Masheck, Thomas McEvilley, Richard Shiff, Kermit Champa, Rosalind Krauss, and Douglas Crimp, but I doubt they are a canon in anyone else’s eyes, and the cloud of names behind them threatens to become infinite: Dave Hickey, Eric Troncy, Peter Plagens, Susan Suleiman, Francesco Bonami, Kim Levin, Helen Molesworth, Donald Kuspit, Buzz Spector, Mira Schor, Hans-Ulrich Obrist, Miwon Kwon, Germano Celant, Giorgio Verzotti—there are hundreds more” (8).



[source]
Elkins, James. What Happened to Art Criticism? Prickly Paradigm Press, 2003.





















12. 

A place to draw the curtains and write. 

He becomes professor of Art History at the School of the Art Institute of Chicago in 1989, where he teaches today and acts as chair of the department. 



[source]
James Elkins's personal website
https://jameselkins.com/brief-bio/.


[ Art Institute of Chicago, 1890
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Art_Institute_of_Chicago]












13.

“[Artists] have idiosyncratic, oblique, eccentric, unpredictable, a-historical, and just plain crazy uses for history. That experience was the beginning of the end of ordinary art historical pedagogy for me.” 





[source]
Nash, Matthew. “A Conversation with James Elkins,” Big Red and Shiny, January 23, 2006, 
https://bigredandshiny.org/3661/a-conversation-with-james-elkins/.









 




14.

“Only short books are sane, people are safe with short books. Writers can control them, but all books are slow-acting poison, they are infected by the author’s mind, and they infect readers in turn, and the longer the book, the more time you spend turning the pages, whether you are writing or reading, the more ill you become. No one controls thoughts that take more than a hundred pages to write. Many books appear to be sane, but that is because they end quickly. Most people seem sane if you talk to them for just a few minutes” from A Short Introduction to Anneliese, 2025, by James Elkins, the second book in a five-part novel, titled Five Strange Languages